Introduction
When deciding how to deal with a squirrel problem, one of the most common questions people ask is about cost. Live catch traps and kill traps are the two main types available, but their prices, features, and long term value can be very different.
This guide explains the price differences between live catch and kill traps, what you get for your money, and how to decide which option is right for your situation.
For readers who want the full picture of squirrel control, you can also explore our complete guide to squirrel traps in the UK.
What are Live Catch and Kill Traps
Live Catch Traps
These are cage style traps designed to catch a squirrel without harming it. Once inside, the door closes and the animal is contained. The main drawback in the UK is that it is illegal to release a grey squirrel once caught. This means anyone using a live catch trap is responsible for dispatching the animal.
Kill Traps
These traps are designed to dispatch the squirrel instantly and humanely. They include traditional spring traps and modern self resetting systems such as Goodnature traps. Kill traps are generally more expensive up front, but they can offer better long term value because they do not require you to handle live animals.
Price Ranges in the UK
Here is a breakdown of typical prices for both types.
| Trap Type | Price Range | Average Lifespan | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Basic live catch trap | £15–£30 | 1–2 years | Affordable, simple to use | You must dispatch the squirrel, needs frequent checking |
| Heavy duty live catch trap | £30–£60 | 3–5 years | Durable, reusable | Larger upfront cost, same legal responsibility |
| Traditional spring kill trap | £40–£60 | 3–5 years | Humane, effective | Must be reset after each use, can catch non-target animals |
| Goodnature self resetting trap | £100–£150 | 5–10 years | Self resetting, weather resistant, humane, low labour | Higher upfront cost, requires CO₂ and lure refills |
Why the Price Difference Matters
When choosing between live catch and kill traps, the upfront price is only part of the story.
Short Term Costs
Live catch traps are cheaper to buy, making them attractive for one-off use. Basic models can be purchased for under twenty pounds.
Long Term Costs
Live catch traps require you to rebait and reset after each capture. Handling live animals can be stressful and time consuming.
Goodnature traps are designed to last for years and automatically reset after each capture. While the initial cost is higher, you save time and labour over the long term.
Total Value
For occasional use, a live catch trap may be cost effective. For ongoing control in gardens, lofts, or farms, a kill trap such as Goodnature often delivers better overall value.
Case Example
A homeowner in Kent purchased two heavy duty live catch traps for £60 in total. Over the course of six months, they caught several squirrels but had to dispatch each one manually. The traps needed rebaiting daily and were prone to rust outdoors.
Another homeowner invested in a Goodnature A18 trap for £135. Over the same period, the trap dispatched multiple squirrels automatically, needed minimal maintenance, and was still in full working order after six months. While the upfront cost was higher, the long term convenience and reliability made it the better investment.
Which Trap is Right for You
Ask yourself:
Do you want the lowest upfront price or the best long term value?
Are you comfortable with the responsibility of dispatching a live squirrel?
Will the trap be used indoors or outdoors, occasionally or regularly?
Do you prefer a low maintenance option even if the upfront cost is higher?
For many homeowners, the answer is that live catch traps are fine for occasional use, but for ongoing control, a humane kill trap such as Goodnature is often the most practical choice.
FAQs
Why are live catch traps cheaper than kill traps?
Live catch traps are simpler to manufacture. They are usually just a cage with a trigger mechanism, while kill traps require stronger materials and precise engineering to ensure a humane kill.
Are expensive traps really more humane?
Yes. More expensive traps such as Goodnature are approved for humane use and are designed to dispatch squirrels instantly. Cheaper traps may not always deliver a quick kill.
How much does it cost to maintain a Goodnature trap?
You will need to replace the CO₂ canister and lure occasionally. A refill kit costs around £25 and lasts for months. Compared with the cost of rebaiting live catch traps daily, this is often cheaper long term.
Can I use a live catch trap and then upgrade later?
Yes. Many people start with live catch traps to save money, then invest in a Goodnature trap once they see how much easier it makes control.
Is it worth paying more for a self resetting trap?
If you have ongoing squirrel problems or live in a rural area, the answer is usually yes. The convenience and reliability outweigh the higher upfront cost.
Linking Back to the Pillar Page
If you would like to learn more about squirrel control in general, read our complete guide to squirrel traps in the UK.
Conclusion
The price differences between live catch and kill traps are clear. Live catch traps are affordable and useful for short term problems, but they require more effort and come with legal responsibilities. Kill traps, particularly modern self resetting traps such as Goodnature, are more expensive up front but offer superior long term value, convenience, and humane performance.
When deciding, consider both the short term budget and the long term reliability. For many UK homeowners, Goodnature traps are a wise investment in effective and ethical squirrel control.