Introduction
Squirrel traps are one of the most effective ways to deal with grey squirrels in the UK. But that does not mean they are always easy to use. Many homeowners buy traps and quickly become frustrated when they do not work as expected. Others worry about whether they are using them legally or humanely.
This article explores the biggest problems people face with squirrel traps and, more importantly, how to solve them. By the end you will know what mistakes to avoid, how to get the best results, and when a modern solution like a Goodnature trap can remove many of these headaches.
For a complete overview of costs, benefits, and step-by-step instructions, take a look at our complete guide to squirrel traps in the UK.
Problem 1: Squirrels Avoid the Trap
One of the most common complaints is that squirrels simply refuse to go near a trap.
Why it happens:
- Squirrels are cautious by nature
- Traps may carry human scent if handled without gloves
- Placement is in the wrong area, away from natural runways
Solutions:
- Wear gloves when handling traps
- Place traps along runways such as fences, beams, or near feeding areas
- Use strong baits such as peanut butter or sunflower seeds
- Pre-bait the area by leaving food near the trap for a few days before setting it
Problem 2: Non-Target Animals Get Caught
Some traps end up catching birds, hedgehogs, or even cats instead of squirrels.
Why it happens:
- Trap placed in open areas
- Bait attractive to other species
- Wrong trap size used
Solutions:
- Place traps inside lofts, under covers, or inside tunnels
- Use heavier baits like nuts rather than bread or seeds that attract birds
- Always choose an approved squirrel trap of the correct size
Goodnature traps reduce this risk by being mounted at height on trees or posts, making them less accessible to non-target animals.
Problem 3: Legal Responsibilities Cause Confusion
Many people are unsure about the law on squirrel trapping.
Key points:
- Grey squirrels cannot legally be released once caught
- Red squirrels are protected and must never be harmed
- All traps must be checked at least once every twenty-four hours
Solution:
Learn the relevant laws before buying. The complete guide to squirrel traps in the UK provides a clear breakdown of your responsibilities.
Problem 4: Traps Are Messy and Unpleasant to Maintain
Handling dead animals, cleaning cages, and rebaiting traps are major concerns for many homeowners.
Solutions:
- Always wear gloves and use disinfectant when cleaning traps
- Dispose of carcasses in line with local council regulations
- Consider traps that reduce handling, such as Goodnature, which are self-resetting and need minimal maintenance
Problem 5: Traps Stop Working Over Time
Cheaper traps may rust outdoors, springs can weaken, and cages may break.
Why it happens:
- Exposure to rain and frost
- Poor build quality
- Lack of cleaning and maintenance
Solutions:
- Buy galvanised or coated steel traps for outdoor use
- Store traps indoors when not in use
- For long-term reliability, invest in Goodnature traps designed to withstand UK weather for years
Comparison of Common Problems Across Trap Types
| Trap Type | Typical Problems | How to Solve Them | Long-Term Reliability |
|---|---|---|---|
| Live catch trap | Squirrels avoid it, daily rebaiting required, must dispatch yourself | Pre-bait, wear gloves, follow legal guidelines | Moderate, rusts if left outdoors |
| Traditional kill trap | Needs resetting after each use, may catch non-target animals | Careful placement, use correct bait, regular maintenance | Moderate, springs weaken over years |
| Goodnature self-resetting trap | Higher upfront cost | Proper mounting and occasional CO₂ refills | High, designed for long-term outdoor use |
FAQs
Why will squirrels not go into my trap?
Squirrels are naturally cautious. Ensure your trap is in a high-traffic area, wear gloves to avoid leaving human scent, and use strong baits like peanut butter.
How can I stop catching birds instead of squirrels?
Use heavier baits such as nuts, and place traps inside lofts or under covers. Goodnature traps reduce this problem by being mounted on trees.
Do I need to check a Goodnature trap every day?
You must check all traps daily under UK law. Goodnature makes this easier with a counter that shows how many activations have occurred.
Are live catch traps still legal?
Yes, but you cannot release grey squirrels once caught. This means you must dispatch them humanely, which many people find difficult.
How long will a Goodnature trap last?
Goodnature traps are designed to last 5–10 years with basic maintenance, making them more reliable than cheaper wire traps.
Why do traps sometimes rust?
Outdoor exposure is the main cause. Always buy galvanised or weather-resistant traps and clean them regularly.
Conclusion
The biggest problems people face with squirrel traps from squirrels avoiding them, to legal confusion, to messy maintenance are all solvable with the right approach.
For occasional use, live catch and traditional kill traps can be effective if handled correctly. But for homeowners who want a reliable, humane, and low-maintenance solution, Goodnature traps solve many of the common frustrations.
If you want more detailed guidance on squirrel traps, including costs, benefits, and step-by-step instructions, you can read our complete guide to squirrel traps in the UK.